Testing the Reliability of a Narrator
Emily Bronte’s choice of narration is both a peculiar and clever one in Wuthering Heights . It is interesting to note her success in this decision as the story unfolds from a stranger's diary who is able to acquire the entire narrative from a servant who witnesses the past events that occur between the Lintons and the Earnshaws. During a recent class discussion, this topic was lightly touched by my fellow peers and they suggested that the retrospect of the past events could not have been told in a more pure manner if it was not told by Nelly Dean . The class discussed how Mrs. Dean was a great choice because she is “neutral” and had an opportunity to live in both Thrushcross Grange and Wuthering Heights; therefore, she knows everything and if the narration was told by someone else it would have been biased. This argument is agreeable, but I think there is more behind Emily Bronte’s choice of Nelly Dean to tell the story. More light is shed on an article entitled The Villain in Wu...